• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
Hit the Trail

Hit the Trail

Phantom Ranch, Grand Canyon, Sedona, & the Southwest

  • Home
  • Hikers Guide
    • Equipment
      • Backcountry Food
      • Backcountry Kitchen Gear
      • Backpacking Stoves
      • Backpacks
      • Boots & Footwear
      • Clothing
      • Equipment Guide
      • Equipment Rentals/Purchase
      • Flashlights and Lanterns
      • Seat Pads
      • Sleeping Bags
      • Sleeping Pads
      • Socks
      • Tents
      • The Wonder Bucket
      • Walking Sticks
      • Water Purification
    • Trails & Campgrounds
      • Bright Angel Campground
      • Cottonwood Camp
      • Desert View
      • Grand Canyon’s Corridor Trails
      • Grand Canyon Trail Descriptions
      • Havasu and Mooney Falls
      • Indian Garden Campground
      • North Rim Campgrounds
      • North Rim Day Hikes
      • North Rim Yurt
      • Pack Hauling Service
      • Phantom Ranch/BA Day Hikes
      • Phantom Ranch Area Map
      • Phantom Ranch FAQs
      • Phantom Ranch Lodging/Dining
      • South Rim Campgrounds
      • South Rim Day Hikes
      • Sedona/Verde Valley Trails
      • Toroweap & Tuweep
      • Trip Reports and Resources
      • Trip Reports – Baja
    • Safety, Resources & Training
      • Acrophobia/Fear of Heights
      • Arizona Hiking Clubs
      • Backcountry 911
      • Backcountry Etiquette
      • Backcountry Permits
      • Bubonic Plague
      • Heat Strain
      • Hiker FAQs
      • Hiker’s Links/Resources
      • Lightning Strikes/Safety Tips
      • Monsoon Facts
      • Rabies
      • Training/Physical Fitness
    • Tips & Tricks
      • Author’s Tips & Tricks
      • Boot Lacing Technique
      • Phantom Ranch Tips & Tricks
      • Readers’ Tips & Tricks
      • Rest Step for Uphill Hiking
      • Summertime Hiking Tips
      • Winter Hiking Tips
      • Women’s Tips & Tricks
  • Visitors Guide
    • General Information
      • Entrance Fees/Park Brochures
      • Events Calendar
      • Fishing Regulations
      • Fires/Smoke in Park
      • Fishing Regulations
      • Grand Canyon Distances
      • Grand Canyon Park Links
      • Grand Canyon Trivia/Facts
      • Grand Canyon Weather
      • Havasu and Mooney Falls
      • Hiking Guides
      • Indian Reservations
      • Photo Galleries
      • Ranger Programs
    • South Rim
      • Desert View
      • Havasu and Mooney Falls
      • South Rim Campgrounds
      • South Rim Day Hikes
      • South Rim Lodging
      • South Rim Mule Rides
      • South Rim Restaurants/Cafés
      • South Rim Services
      • South Rim Transportation
    • Phantom Ranch
      • Pack Hauling/Duffel Service
      • Phantom Ranch Area Map
      • Phantom Ranch/BA Day Hikes
      • Phantom Ranch FAQs
      • Phantom Ranch Human History
      • Phantom Ranch Lodging/Dining
      • Phantom Mule Ride Gallery
      • Phantom Ranch Mule Rides
      • Phantom Ranch Tips & Tricks
    • North Rim
      • North Rim Campgrounds
      • North Rim Day Hikes
      • North Rim Dining/Food Service
      • North Rim Lodging
      • North Rim Mule Rides
      • North Rim Services
      • North Rim Yurt
      • Toroweap & Tuweep
    • Sedona
      • Permitted Guide Services
      • Red Rock Pass
      • Sedona Geology
      • Sedona Information
      • Sedona Photography
      • Sedona/Verde Valley Area Trails
      • Visitor Centers
  • Mules, Guides & River Trips
    • Commercial River Trips
    • Hiking Guides
    • Horseback Rides
    • Mule Ride Gallery
    • North Rim Mule Rides
    • Pack Hauling/Duffel Service
    • Phantom Ranch Mule Rides
    • Private River Trips
    • River Trip Safety
    • South Rim Mule Rides
  • Explore
    • Natural History
      • Bats
      • Canyon Treefrogs
      • Condors at Grand Canyon
      • Ravens
      • Scorpions
      • Snakes
      • Squirrels & Rodents
      • Tarantulas/Other Spiders
    • Human History
      • Civilian Conservation Corps
      • Phantom Ranch History
      • Pre-Park Era
      • NPS Era
    • Grand Canyon Geology
      • Intro to Grand Canyon Geology
      • Kaibab Limestone to Supai Formation
      • Redwall Limestone to Tapeats Sandstone
      • The Supergroup
      • The Inner Gorge
    • Lake Powell Geology
      • Introduction
      • The Back Story
      • Rock Layers
      • Monoclines
      • Prominent Rock Units
      • Striking Landscape
      • Laccoliths
      • Future of Lake Powell
    • Sedona Geology
      • Introduction
      • Prelude to the Red Rocks
      • Sedona’s Red Rocks, Part 1
      • Sedona’s Red Rocks, Part 2
      • Deposition, Uplift, and Erosion
      • House Mountain Volcano
      • Verde Valley and Verde Lake
      • Carving Oak Creek Canyon
  • Books & Videos
    • Hiking Guides
      • Apps, Maps & Hiking DVDs
      • Arizona Hiking
      • Canyon Country Hiking
      • Grand Canyon Hiking
      • Utah Hiking
    • Hiker Safety/Skills
      • Backcountry Skills
      • Camper’s Cookbooks
      • Search and Rescue
      • Wilderness First Aid
    • Natural/Human History
      • Grand Canyon Human History
      • Grand Canyon Legends
      • Natural History & Geology Guides
    • Colorado Plateau
      • Exploring Arizona
      • Exploring Utah
      • Regional Guides
      • Scenic Photography Books
  • Blog
    • Canyon Posts
    • Canyon Archives
    • Trip Reports
    • Baja Trip Archive – Baja
    • Site Contributors
Home/Hikers Column/Congress in ’98: Utah monument complies with Antiquities Act

Congress in ’98: Utah monument complies with Antiquities Act

Grand Staircase-Escalante NM | BLM Photo
Grand Staircase-Escalante NM | BLM Photo

A newly available document released by the Bureau of Land Management (BLM) shows Congress affirmed that the initial boundaries of Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument complied with the Antiquities Act.


Draft RMP cover | BLM

The document, a land-swap agreement between the federal government and the state of Utah (PDF – 140 kb), was ratified by Congress and signed into law by President Bill Clinton in 1998. The agreement also stipulates that former Utah stand-land inholdings were to be managed as part of the monument.

The agreement contained no provisions that would allow the transferred inholdings to be removed from Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument or managed separately. The agreement was approved in Public Law 105-335, The Utah Schools and Lands Exchange Act of 1998.

The bill passed in the Republican-majority House without dissent, enjoyed unanimous approval in the Republican-majority Senate, and was signed into law by President Clinton1.

The law states that “all terms, conditions, procedures, covenants, reservations, and other provisions set forth in the [land-swap agreement] … are ratified, confirmed, and set forth the obligations and commitments of the United States, the State of Utah, and Utah School and Institutional Trust Lands Administration (herein referred to as ‘SITLA’), as a matter of Federal law.”

The bill approving the agreement is readily available online 2, and it has been cited in legal challenges to the monument reduction 3. Although its implications have been discussed in the press 4, the agreement itself has not been widely available until its recent release by the BLM in response to a Freedom of Information Act request.

The agreement declares at the outset that the monument was created by President Clinton “pursuant to Section 2 of the Antiquities Act 5,” which states that monuments “shall be confined to the smallest area compatible with proper care and management of the objects to be protected.”

The affirmation that the monument was created pursuant to Section 2 is significant, as President Donald Trump cited an opposite conclusion as his rationale for reducing the size of the monument by 47% 6. His December 2017 proclamation to reduce the monument the was preceded by an August 2017 report from Secretary of the Interior Ryan Zinke recommending the action 7. The report provided the same rationale as the proclamation.

Prior to the land-swap agreement, land ownership in the Grand Staircase-Escalante region was characterized by large areas of BLM-managed federal lands intermixed with a checkerboard of state-land inholdings. As part of the land-swap agreement transferring those inholdings from state to federal ownership, the agreement stipulated that “any lands or interests therein acquired by the United States within the exterior boundaries of the Monument … shall become a part of the Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument, and shall be subject to all the laws and regulations applicable to the Monument.”

However, the lands declared excluded from the monument by President Trump include some of those former state-land inholdings. These excluded lands are now open to mining 8.

According to Tim Peterson, Utah Wildlands Program Director for the Grand Canyon Trust 9, “A total of eight lode claims were located by individuals from Utah in March of 2018, then acquired by Canada-based Glacier Lake Resources in June of 2018.

The claims are located at Colt Mesa in the Circle Cliffs region on lands that President Trump attempted to cut from the monument in December 2017. The parcel is one that was formerly owned by the state of Utah; ownership was transferred to the United States under the Utah Schools and Lands Exchange Act of 1998 to be protected in the Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument 10.”

Draft RMP cost estimate

Legal challenges to reductions of Grand Staircase-Escalante and other monuments are ongoing. Meanwhile, the BLM is proceeding with a new resource management plan for Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument and the lands President Trump ordered to be removed from it. The BLM has estimated the cost of producing a new draft plan 11 at over $1.1 million.

“When the courts rule that President Trump’s December 2017 order slashing the monument is illegal, the new plans will be headed for the recycle bin, and the money spent on them will have been squandered,” says Peterson. “The BLM has wasted over a million dollars so far on planning for the illegally reduced Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument. Those funds would have been much better spent on resource protection, visitation management, science grants to study the monument’s world-class paleontology, or improving interpretation at important and sensitive cultural and paleontological sites.”

Requests for comment from the BLM were not answered. Resource management-plan scoping-phase materials 12 from the BLM indicate that the agency will not consider “general legal concerns” about the monument reduction. Interested parties can comment on the draft plan online 13.

Footnotes

  1. https://www.congress.gov/bill/105th-congress/house-bill/3830/actions
  2. https://www.congress.gov/105/plaws/publ335/PLAW-105publ335.pdf
  3. https://www.nrdc.org/sites/default/files/complaint-grand-staircase-escalante-20171204.pdf
  4. https://www.eenews.net/stories/1060053899
  5. https://www.nps.gov/subjects/legal/the-antiquities-act-of-1906.htm
  6. https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/presidential-proclamation-modifying-grand-staircase-escalante-national-monument/
  7. https://www.doi.gov/sites/doi.gov/files/uploads/revised_final_report.pdf

Published on: September 10, 2018

Categories: Hikers ColumnTags: Antiquities Act, Bureau of Land Management (BLM), Grand Canyon Trust, Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument, President Donald Trump, Secretary of the Interior Ryan Zinke, SITLA

About Mike Campbell

After leaving a decade-long career in computational chemistry, Mike Campbell founded Canyonology Treks in 2014. Although Canyonology Treks is a young company, it has a long backstory.

Before moving to northern Arizona, Mike and his wife Amanda were avid hikers living in Portland, Oregon. When they met, Mike and Amanda had already spent years living, hiking, and camping across the West.

When a job opportunity presented Amanda with the opportunity to return to the Grand Canyon area, they made the leap together.

Today, Amanda teaches in Arizona and Mike is a full-time guide.

https://www.canyonology.com/

Primary Sidebar

Search

Recent News

Havasu Creek | Photo by Mike Buchheit

Important Updates – and Fascinating Stuff Too!

Fire Restrictions Going Into Effect Friday, May 14 The Kaibab National Forest (the national …

Continue Reading about Important Updates – and Fascinating Stuff Too!

Important Inner Canyon Closures and East Entrance Opening

Temporary Closures Along the Silver Bridge and Bright Angel Trail The Grand Canyon announced …

Continue Reading about Important Inner Canyon Closures and East Entrance Opening

Archives

  • Hit the Trail Returns with New Partnership
  • Hit the Trail Resumes with Limited Updates
  • Important Updates for Park

Newsletter

Sign up for email updates. You can stop at any time and your information will never be shared.

Footer

Copyright © 1998–2023 · Hit the Trail: Phantom Ranch, Grand Canyon, Sedona and the Southwest

All Rights Reserved · All photos credit NPS unless stated otherwise

Newsletter

Sign up for email updates. You can stop at any time and your information will never be shared.

  • Contact
  • About
  • Sitemap
  • Affiliate Disclaimer